Shooting a 'dolly' linear pano [Archive] - Nodal Ninja Forum

PDA

View Full Version : Shooting a 'dolly' linear pano



M1ke_a
01-11-2011, 01:43 AM
I thought I'd be able to shoot a rectilinearly correct pano by taking a series of shots from L - R, following a straight line and moving the tripod between each shot.

I'd like to create a Hi Res photographic version of of these elevation style paintings - http://www.locos-in-profile.co.uk/Prints/LNER/A4/Mallard.html, shooting something like 6 or more portraits shots for maximum coverage.

I've tried two experiments thus far and both have been abject failures. One was with the Tok 10-17 fish and other with my Canon 17-40 @ 17mm.

I thought if you were parallel to the subject PTGUI would cope with the lens distortion and happily overlap the scenes?

I suspect I'm doing something fundamentally wrong so has anyone tried such a project and can point me in the right direction?

hindenhaag
01-11-2011, 03:21 AM
Hi,

I think this will help you a little bit: http://www.dojoe.net/tutorials/linear-pano/

http://hugin.sourceforge.net/tutorials/scans/en.shtml

Cheers,
Heinz

Hugh
01-11-2011, 04:16 AM
Hello Mike_a,

What you are suggesting is similar to creating photo mosaics from aerial photography taken for photogrammetric mapping where an aircraft flies in a straight line taking photographs at an interval to give a 60% overlap (so there is a 10% overlap between every other photograph).
The photo mosaic was created by "fitting" common points in each overlap.
However, this technique was based on the assumption that the ground was relatively flat (i.e. changes in elevation were small when compared with the flying height) so that the perspective for each photograph can be ignored and I feel that this is where attempting this in the way you suggest will unfortunately fail.

To give an idea of what I am trying to describe:
Say the subject was two parallel lines of poles parallel to your camera positions.
If you "fitted" the photographs using the line of poles nearest the line of your camera positions then each of the poles in the line away from the line of your camera positions will appear both to the left and the right of the poles nearest the camera, so somehow you would need to remove the perspective from each image to create an orthographic image (an image where the subject is at right angles to the image plane rather than radiating from the camera).

To get the solution to work you would need to either find a way of changing the perspective image created by the camera into an orthographic image or chose a subject with very little difference in distance from the camera (e.g. a row of shop fronts) and ignore the perspective.
You would then need to "fit" the images manually or use a package designed for "fitting" multiple scans together (merge documents), such as PanoramaStudio (http://www.tshsoft.de/en/index.html)

I hope this helps.
Best regards, Hugh.

Hugh
01-11-2011, 04:19 AM
The suggestion from Heinz (thanks Heinz) works because the subject is effectively a plane.
Hugh.

M1ke_a
01-11-2011, 08:18 AM
Thanks for the input guys.

Heinz

I'll have a look at those other apps and see how I get on.

Hugh

I hadn't considered aerial mosaics and I guess in the scheme of things, these are going to be even more complex to accurately join. You take things like Google Maps et al for granted so thanks for bringing that subject up.