Which Quick Release for a NN5 [Archive] - Nodal Ninja Forum

PDA

View Full Version : Which Quick Release for a NN5



Gandalf
08-11-2009, 02:13 AM
Hi guys,

I bough one of the early NN5 in 2008.
I noticed that there are 2 types of quick release systems available for the NN5 : The Fanotec's one at (39,95$ for the full set) and the Arca Swiss compatible (44,95$ for the clamp + 24,95$ for the plate).
What are the differences between this two systems ?
Even if I know that NN5 is not batchable, my aim is to approach repeatable results.
Which one should I go with ?

Thank you
Gandalf

Bill Bailey
08-11-2009, 05:44 AM
Hi guys,

I bough one of the early NN5 in 2008.
I noticed that there are 2 types of quick release systems available for the NN5 : The Fanotec's one at (39,95$ for the full set) and the Arca Swiss compatible (44,95$ for the clamp + 24,95$ for the plate).
What are the differences between this two systems ?
Even if I know that NN5 is not batchable, my aim is to approach repeatable results.
Which one should I go with ?

Thank you
Gandalf

Hi Gandalf,
Both quick release systems will work for you. Many people already use the Arca style system (dovetail mounting) so for them we offer either the clamp or plate but due to increase manufacturing costs they sell for a bit more. The standard quick release system ($39.95) is excellent value and should work just fine for you.
We do not claim or recommend our customers to attempt repeatable results for batch stitching. For this you would need a competitors pano head costing twice the cost of a NN5.
thank you
Bill

Gandalf
08-11-2009, 06:28 AM
Bill, thank you for your quick answer.

So there is no difference between the two models ? just a matter of compatibilty with Arca ?

nick fan
08-11-2009, 08:55 AM
Bill, thank you for your quick answer.

So there is no difference between the two models ? just a matter of compatibilty with Arca ?


The Arca style QR system is CNC machined and anodized from aluminum alloy. It is higher quality and more durable.
The QRS2 is die cast and painted.


Nick

panoguy
08-11-2009, 12:28 PM
The Arca-style quick-release system is very nice, and extremely solid when clamped. (No experience with the less-expensive one) "Arca-style" means a specific size and shape of dovetail mounting that many higher-end photographic equipment manufacturers support (you can get plates from Kirk, RRS, Wimberly, Arca-Swiss, Linhof, NodalNinja, etc.). I use a Kirk plate which fits into the NN Arca release, and on my Markins ball-head. Both are rock-solid.

Before the Arca-style release from NN, I had mounted a Manfrotto RC2 clamp to my NN5 and it was "repeatable" if not exactly rock-solid. I switched because I got a new ball-head that was Arca (and solid), and frankly the RC2 system required a lot of "fiddling" to get the plate well-mounted.

Gandalf
08-11-2009, 12:49 PM
@Bill, @Nick, thanks for your explanations

@Panoguy. Thank you very much for your testimonial.
That finished to convince me to go for an arca compatible one :001_smile:

jrsforums
08-13-2009, 09:26 PM
The Arca style QR system is CNC machined and anodized from aluminum alloy. It is higher quality and more durable.
The QRS2 is die cast and painted.



Is this the ASQRC-2?

How does this QR compare (other than price) with an RRS lever QR clamp and the RP1-38 Rail Plate. I am assuming the RRS B2 LR II: 60mm LR clamp, which has the 3/8" tap.

While I am asking, is the ASQRP-1 plate compatible with the RRS lever clamps, or only AS-type screw clamps?


Thanks....JOHN

jrsforums
08-13-2009, 09:52 PM
In the NN5 User Manual, page 4, it shows a 70-200 lens mounted to the upper arm with the lens collar mount.

Is this possible with any of the AS QR solutions? (The obvious challenge is that the len collar plate is 90' to the camera plate orientation)

John

nick fan
08-13-2009, 11:54 PM
Is this the ASQRC-2?

How does this QR compare (other than price) with an RRS lever QR clamp and the RP1-38 Rail Plate. I am assuming the RRS B2 LR II: 60mm LR clamp, which has the 3/8" tap.

While I am asking, is the ASQRP-1 plate compatible with the RRS lever clamps, or only AS-type screw clamps?


Thanks....JOHN


Our plate is compatible with screw clamp only.

Nick

nick fan
08-13-2009, 11:56 PM
In the NN5 User Manual, page 4, it shows a 70-200 lens mounted to the upper arm with the lens collar mount.

Is this possible with any of the AS QR solutions? (The obvious challenge is that the len collar plate is 90' to the camera plate orientation)

John


The ASQRC2 allows both directions (parallel and perpendicular to the rail). So it is compatible with lens collar.

Nick

jrsforums
08-14-2009, 01:05 AM
Our plate is compatible with screw clamp only.

Nick


Bummer...but thanks for reply.

I use RRS Lever clamps. Can you recommend RRS or Wimberly plate which will best attach to NN5 rotator base (or future, if upgraded, D16 base)? I would like to minimize any torque twisting and do not know dimensions (diameter) or possible mounting taps (other that tripod in center).

John

jrsforums
08-14-2009, 01:08 AM
The ASQRC2 allows both directions (parallel and perpendicular to the rail). So it is compatible with lens collar.

Nick



That is great. Seems the way to go and superior to other clamp with 3/8" low profile rail.

John

nick fan
08-14-2009, 04:45 AM
Bummer...but thanks for reply.

I use RRS Lever clamps. Can you recommend RRS or Wimberly plate which will best attach to NN5 rotator base (or future, if upgraded, D16 base)? I would like to minimize any torque twisting and do not know dimensions (diameter) or possible mounting taps (other that tripod in center).

John


I have no idea for the plate. Preferably, the plate should use a 3/8" screw. Then you can use 2 screws to mount the plate on the rotator base. Otherwise you need 2 1/4"-3/8" adapter screws.
Skimming through RRS catalog, I find their "Special Fore-CAft Style Plate". The B22 and B29 should work best.


NIck

jrsforums
08-14-2009, 07:18 AM
I have no idea for the plate. Preferably, the plate should use a 3/8" screw. Then you can use 2 screws to mount the plate on the rotator base. Otherwise you need 2 1/4"-3/8" adapter screws.
Skimming through RRS catalog, I find their "Special Fore-CAft Style Plate". The B22 and B29 should work best.


Thanks, Nick...

What is the diameter of the NN5 rotator base. I assume one of the 3/8" holes is in the center for tripod mounting. What is the center to center distance to the other 3/8" hole?

John

jrsforums
08-14-2009, 07:24 AM
Just went to order NN5L and AS-QR clamp. The clamp is out of stock. When is expected to be back in stock? Do you take back orders?

John

nick fan
08-14-2009, 09:49 AM
Thanks, Nick...

What is the diameter of the NN5 rotator base. I assume one of the 3/8" holes is in the center for tripod mounting. What is the center to center distance to the other 3/8" hole?

John


rotator diameter is 60mm. 2 3/8" sockets are about 12mm (0.5") apart.

Nick

nick fan
08-14-2009, 09:50 AM
Just went to order NN5L and AS-QR clamp. The clamp is out of stock. When is expected to be back in stock? Do you take back orders?

John


The clamp will be in stock next week.

Nick